Alcohol and Drug informational resource

Doctor, Doctor give me the cure, give me an opinion that would endure

Doctor, Doctor give me the cure, an opinion that  would endure

What Exactly Is the Doctor’s Opinion

Aug 18, 2011 10:04 pm

Nowadays it seems that those whose opinions matter the most are too gun shy to share them for fear of having their words twisted, their reputations destroyed, lawsuits brought upon them and so on.  Not so with the alcoholic though, we’re generally more than eager to broadcast our opinions, especially if they are fully grounded in insanity.  Fortunately, the authors of the Big Book were well aware of the general public’s intolerance for the alcoholic’s opinion and decided to focus solely on their experiences.  With even greater foresight the authors sought the opinion of one of the most respected professionals of their era, the doctor.

“Sometimes the questions are complicated and the answers are simple.”

— Dr. Seuss

With his many years of experience in treating the alcoholics and drug addicts of his time, Dr. Silkworth was able to develop a disease model for alcoholism that incorporated the physical component as well as the mental, an idea that had begun to generate widespread support amongst his peers in the medical community.  Though that concept allowed them to understand the alcoholic situation through a new standard of diagnostics, it brought them no closer to finding a cure for the condition.  All of a sudden one of his hopelessly chronic patients, Bill Wilson, began to put some of the pieces together and “acquired certain ideas concerning a possible means of recovery.”  Some of these pieces came from the doctor, such as the physical allergy, mental obsession and vicious cycle that we will soon be reading about.  Other pieces came from Ebby, such as the spiritual shortcoming and spreading the word with other alcoholics.  Another piece came from his sudden and profound spiritual experience.  In essence, Bill had found a cure, for lack of a better word.  That cure was sharing what he had learned with other alcoholics so they could share with still more.  Dr. Silkworth had seen this method work many times over for previously hopeless alcoholics and their families and instantly recognized its significance and possibilities.

“All truths are easy to understand once they are discovered; the point is to discover them.”

Galileo Galilei

For some of us we turn to “The Doctor’s Opinion” early on in our talks with the new member in order to show them what alcoholism looks like in their lives, and it can be easy to believe that the doctor’s opinion is all about the disease concept.  That isn’t so.  The doctor’s opinion is that the solution laid out in the rest of the book, Alcoholics Anonymous, is the absolute remedy for the disease of alcoholism.  He is the “heavy” that weighed in to give our text his seal of approval and professional, medical validation.

Charley P.  Austin, TX.

See you on the radio



Leave a Reply

Recent Posts

  •         By Bob k “Jack Alexander, Saturday Evening Post, was also one of the friends to whom Bill sent material. Of the Twelve Tradition essays, Alexander has this to say: ‘The only serious (in my view) defect is that you have treated the old Washingtonian Society too briefly; most people never heard […]


  •   A.A. has quietly acknowledged, primarily through one publication, that the early A.A. pioneers in Akron believed firmly that the answer to all their problems was in the Good Book, as they called the Bible. A.A. co-founder Dr. Bob said that all the basic ideas were taken from their study of the Good Book. And […]


  • Some people don’t know me and they don’t like me, some people get to know me and then they don’t like me, its none of my business what you think of me because you think so little of me anyway, if not in stature surely in time Now you are free to be your authentic […]


  • Happy Birthday Recovered Its all about the upholstery, the old stuffing has been replaced with the cushion of grace and a new skin that is scotch guarded with the humility of faith while the utility of the strong back to service is firmly put in place, this instead of ending up on the junk heap […]


  •   THE FICKLE FINGER OF FATE   Happiness is way over rated as it is dependent on the immediate external circumstance. I.E. I am happy because I just won the lottery, I am happy because she said yes,  I am happy because I just had purchased a new car, and just as quickly I am […]


  •     Sisyphus was a Titan that was cursed by the gods to roll a boulder everyday up the side of a mountain and at night it would roll back down to the bottom and for him to repeat the task again and again for all eternity. When the gods came to gloat at his […]


  •     Sitting at the edge of the lap pool I was appraising my physique once athletic and toned as it had boasted of  strength and  the glory of youth now reduced to a state of age and over indulgence, as it reminded me of the body of the laughing Buddha, this insight struck me […]


  •     Alcohol and drugs are equal opportunity destroyers. The disease takes no heed to your particular flavor of addiction labeling it as such is the much greater affliction. The divisions started with Bill Wilson’s “singleness of porpoise” which I believe dose not hold any water, then or now creating the indignation of the drunken […]


  •   Often times in the addiction recovery arena it is claimed that they have been saved by grace. Consider that according to Google (a thousand years hence the anthropologists will have concluded that as a society they all communed with an all knowing god named Google) that there are 140,000,000 drunks in the world. Accordingly to the […]


  •     Sisyphus was a Titan that was cursed by the gods to roll a boulder everyday up the side of a mountain and at night it would roll back down to the bottom and for him to repeat the task again and again for all eternity. When the gods came to gloat at his […]


Mission Statement

Our mission is to inform, inspire, and empower alcoholics anonymous sponsorship locally and internationally to be their very best --- both personally and spiritually.

I would like to acknowledge Hamilton B and his tireless work in the recovery community and his work "Twelve Step Sponsorship How it works" a Hazelton publication and his permission to use what ever was needed to make possible my ongoing sponsorship workshop and Step study and this website.